[DS9] Season Two Rating Comparisons

Leave a reply

We’re once again looking at what other people have said about Star Trek, in this case season two of Deep Space Nine. We took the ratings from a few different reviewers and calculated what their scores would be out of 100. They originally didn’t rate the episodes with that exact scale, but we tried to accurately translate their rating.

The reviewers we’re looking at are Jordan Hoffman, who writes for StarTrek.com, Jamahl Epsicokhan who runs Jammer’s Reviews, Kethinov, and Treknobabble. Treknobabble’s scores are a combined rating from two reviewers, so keep in mind their scale is slightly different.

The episode that seemed to bore everyone was Second Sight, which ended up with the low score of 34.5.

Here are the top 5 rated episode:

1. Blood Oath – 85.5
2. Necessary Evil – 82
3. (tie) The Maquis Part II and The Wire – 81.5
5. The Jem’Hadar – 79.5

There were a few episodes that seemed a little controversial. Crossover (the mirror universe episode)  was given the max score by Jordan Hoffman and Jammer, low scores from Kethinov and Treknobabble, and an average score from us.

Here’s the complete episode scores with breakdowns on how everyone rated the show:

The HomecomingThe homecoming
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 3/5 = 60
Jordan Hoffman: 4/5 = 80
Jammer’s Reviews: 3.5/4 = 87.5
Kethinov: 6/10 = 60
Treknobabble: 7/10 = 70
–
Average: 71.5
–

–

–
The CircleKira The Circle

Let’s Watch Star Trek: 3/5 = 60
Jordan Hoffman: 5/5 = 100
Jammer’s Reviews: 3/4 = 75
Kethinov: 4/10 = 40
Treknobabble: 8/10 = 80
–
Average: 71
–

–

–
The SiegeThe Seige
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 3/5 = 60
Jordan Hoffman: 4/5 = 80
Jammer’s Reviews: 3/4 = 75
Kethinov: 5/10 = 50
Treknobabble: 6/10 = 60
–
Average: 65
–

–

–
Invasive ProceduresInvasive Procedures
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 3/5 = 60
Jordan Hoffman: 3/5 = 60
Jammer’s Reviews: 3/4 = 75
Kethinov: 6/10 = 60
Treknobabble: 6/10 = 60
–
Average: 63
–

–

–
CardassiansCardassians
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 3/5 = 60
Jordan Hoffman: 3/5 = 60
Jammer’s Reviews: 3.5/4 = 87.5
Kethinov: 6/10 = 60
Treknobabble: 7/10 = 70
–
Average: 67.5
–

–

–
MeloraMelora
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 2/5 = 40
Jordan Hoffman: 3/5 = 60
Jammer’s Reviews: 2/4 = 50
Kethinov: 2/10 = 20
Treknobabble: 6/10 = 60
–
Average: 46
–

–

–
Rules of AcquisitionRules of Aquisition
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 2/5 = 40
Jordan Hoffman: 4/5 = 80
Jammer’s Reviews: 2/4 = 50
Kethinov: 8/10 = 80
Treknobabble: 6/10 = 60
–
Average: 62
–

–

–
Necessary Evil Necessary Evil
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 4/5 = 80
Jordan Hoffman: 3/5 = 60
Jammer’s Reviews: 4/4 = 100
Kethinov: 8/10 = 80
Treknobabble: 9/10 = 90
–
Average: 82
–

–

–
Second SightSecond Sight
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 1/5 = 20
Jordan Hoffman: 1/5 = 20
Jammer’s Reviews: 2.5/4 = 62.5
Kethinov: 3/10 = 30
Treknobabble: 4/10 = 40
–
Average: 34.5
–

–

–
SanctuarySanctuary
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 2/5 = 40
Jordan Hoffman: 4/5 = 80
Jammer’s Reviews: 2/4 = 50
Kethinov: 2/10 = 20
Treknobabble: 4/10 = 40
–
Average: 46
–

–

–
RivalsRivals
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 2/5 = 40
Jordan Hoffman: 2/5 = 40
Jammer’s Reviews: 2.5/4 = 62.5
Kethinov: 7/10 = 70
Treknobabble: 4/10 = 40
–
Average: 50.5
–

–

–
The AlternateThe Alternate
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 2/5 = 40
Jordan Hoffman: 2/5 = 40
Jammer’s Reviews: 2.5/4 = 62.5
Kethinov: 3/10 = 30
Treknobabble: 4/10 = 40
–
Average: 42.5
–

–

–
Armageddon GameArmageddon Game
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 3/5 = 60
Jordan Hoffman: 4/5 = 80
Jammer’s Reviews: 3/4 = 75
Kethinov: 5/10 = 50
Treknobabble: 6/10 = 60
–
Average: 65
–

–

–
WhispersWhispers
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 2/5 = 40
Jordan Hoffman: 4.5/5 = 90
Jammer’s Reviews: 4/4 = 100
Kethinov: 4/10 = 40
Treknobabble: 8/10 = 80
–
Average: 70
–

–

–
ParadiseParadise
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 3/5 = 60
Jordan Hoffman: 2/5 = 40
Jammer’s Reviews: 3/4 = 75
Kethinov: 3/10 = 30
Treknobabble: 6/10 = 60
–
Average: 53
–

–

–

ShadowplayShadowplay
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 2/5 = 40
Jordan Hoffman: 3/5 = 60
Jammer’s Reviews: 2.5/4 = 62.5
Kethinov: 5/10 = 50
Treknobabble: 6/10 = 60
–
Average: 54.5
–

–

–
Playing GodPlaying God
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 2/5 = 40
Jordan Hoffman: 2/5 = 40
Jammer’s Reviews: 2.5/4 = 62.5
Kethinov: 1/10 = 10
Treknobabble: 5/10 = 50
–
Average: 40.5
–

–

–
Profit and LossProfit and Loss
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 3/5 = 60
Jordan Hoffman: 4/5 = 80
Jammer’s Reviews: 2/4 = 50
Kethinov: 6/10 = 60
Treknobabble: 6/10 = 60
–
Average: 62
–

–

–
Blood Oath Blood Oath
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 4/5 = 80
Jordan Hoffman: 5/5 = 100
Jammer’s Reviews: 3.5/4 = 87.5
Kethinov: 7/10 = 70
Treknobabble: 9/10 = 90
–
Average: 85.5
–

–

–

The Maquis, Part IThe Maquis part 1
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 3/5 = 60
Jordan Hoffman: 4/5 = 80
Jammer’s Reviews: 3.5/4 = 87.5
Kethinov: 7/10 = 70
Treknobabble: 8/10 = 80
–
Average: 75.5
–

–

–

The Maquis, Part IIThe Maquis part II
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 4/5 = 80
Jordan Hoffman: 5/5 = 100
Jammer’s Reviews: 3.5/4 = 87.5
Kethinov: 8/10 = 80
Treknobabble: 6/10 = 60
–
Average: 81.5
–

–

–

The WireThe Wire
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 4/5 = 80
Jordan Hoffman: 4/5 = 80
Jammer’s Reviews: 3.5/4 = 87.5
Kethinov: 8/10 = 80
Treknobabble: 8/10 = 80
–
Average: 81.5
–

–

–

CrossoverCrossover
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 3/5 = 60
Jordan Hoffman: 5/5 = 100
Jammer’s Reviews: 4/4 = 100
Kethinov: 5/10 = 50
Treknobabble: 4/10 = 40
–
Average: 70
–

–

–

The CollaboratorThe Collaborator
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 2/5 = 40
Jordan Hoffman: 3/5 = 60
Jammer’s Reviews: 3/4 = 75
Kethinov: 4/10 = 40
Treknobabble: 5/10 = 50
–
Average: 53
–

–

–

TribunalTribunal
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 2/5 = 40
Jordan Hoffman: 4/5 = 80
Jammer’s Reviews: 3/4 = 75
Kethinov: 5/10 = 50
Treknobabble: 8/10 = 80
–
Average: 65
–

–

–

The Jem’HadarThe Jem'Hadar
Let’s Watch Star Trek: 4/5 = 80
Jordan Hoffman: 3/5 = 60
Jammer’s Reviews: 3.5/4 = 87.5
Kethinov: 9/10 = 90
Treknobabble: 8/10 = 80
–
Average: 79.5
–

–

–